Stay informed. Stay inspired. Subscribe to our email list.

Close X
  • Join
  •     |    
  • Login
  •     |    
Log in

« Back to Resources

The Impact of Legal Counsel on Outcomes for Poor Tenants in New York City’s Housing Court: Results of a Randomized Experiment

This article was written for the Law and Society Review.

This article presents results of the first randomized experimental evaluation of a legal assistance program for low-income tenants in New York City’s Housing Court.  While almost all landlords in Housing Court have the benefit of legal representation, the vast majority of tenants do not.  The results demonstrate that the provision of legal counsel produces large differences in outcomes for low-income tenants in housing court, independent of the merits of the case.

For example, only 22% of represented tenants had final judgments against them, compared with 51% of tenants without legal representation. Similarly large advantages for tenants with an attorney were found in eviction orders and stipulations requiring the landlord to provide rent abatements or repairs. In addition, the results suggest that a program of legal assistance for low-income tenants would not increase significantly the number of appearances in court, although it would increase the number of days to final judgment. The program may enhance the efficiency of adjudication by reducing the number of motions filed, particularly post-judgment motions. Limitations and policy implications of the study are discussed.

Uploaded on: Dec 02, 2015
Year Published: 2001

Resource Tags

Resource Type: Impact Evidence Issues: Housing Rights & Informal Settlements, Legal Aid & Public Interest Law Tool Type: Journal Articles & Books Languages: English Regions: North America Nature of Impact: Acquisition of Remedy / Entitlement / Information, Conflict resolution / Case resolution Scale of Intervention/Impact: 0 to 1,000 people Institutions Engaged: Local Court Evaluation Method: Project Document Review, Randomized Control Trials, Secondary Data Analysis